Wednesday, March 21, 2012


"Special Education, like so many other reforms won by the popular struggle, has been transformed from a way to increase the probability that students with disabilities will get some kind of an education into a badge of inferiority and a rule-bound, bureaucratic process of separating and then warehousing millions of young people that the dominant culture has no need for.  While this process is uneven, with a minority benefitting from true inclusionary practices, the overarching influences of race and class preclude any significant and meaningful equalization of educational opportunities."

Source: Charlton, J.I. (1998) Nothing About Us Without Us: Disability Oppression and Empowerment. Berkley and Los Angelos, California: University of California Press, p. 33.


"In sum, I believe disability is a marginalized status that society assigns to people who are different enough from majority cultural standards to be judged abnormal or defective in mind or body....But in an ideal world, my differences, though noted, would not be devalued.  Nor would I.  Society would accept my experience as ‘disability culture,’ which would in turn be accepted as part of ‘human diversity.’  There would be respectful curiosity about what I have learned from my differences that I could teach society.  In such a world, no one would mind being called 'Disabled.'"

Source: Charlton, J.I. (1998) Nothing About Us Without Us: Disability Oppression and Empowerment. Berkley and Los Angelos, California: University of California Press, p. 120, quoting Carol Gill.


          “The pattern of exclusion introduced by the eugenics movement blended beliefs regarding the genetics of disabilitites with beliefs regarding the racial inferiority of non-White peoples.  Using the mental-testing movement as the main vehicle for applying the gospel of efficiency to education (Fass, 1991; Gould, 1981), American education became committed to the goal of sorting children.  The construction of special education reflected and supported that goal, and by the middle of the century, special classes for ‘slow learners’ were already showing high rates of placement (Gould, 1981).  After the Brown desegregation decision (Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas, 1954), special education classes became a vehicle for continued segregation, based on presumed lerning deficits (Ferri & Connor, 2005).  As these placements were challenged in the courts and in scholarly publications, the blending of special education and minority placements gradually came to public attention (e.g. Diana v. State Board of Education, 1970; Dunn, 1968; Larry P. v. Riles, 1979; Mercer, 1973)…
                The challenge of an increasingly heterogeneous student population was met by institutionalizing the concept of individual deficit…Thus, sometime in the early 1970s, the special education movement and the desegregation movement officially collided.  Those whom the society had rejected, and had excluded from its public schools, would meet in the special education system.  The concept of deficit, by then an ingrained part of the educational belief system, would become the chief metaphor to encompass difference.”

Source: Harry, B. & Klinger, J. (2006) Why Are So Many Minority Students in Special Education? Understanding Race & Disability in Schools. New York: Teachers College Press, pp. 11-12.


            “We are confident in our finding that the overrepresentation of minorities in special education programs is caused by much more than the existence of intrinsic or family based deficits.  Indeed, the perception that a child is disabled results from a complex weave of widely varying beliefs, policies, and practices at all levels—family and community, classroom, school, district, state and federal government, and society at large.
            In framing the problem so broadly we run the risk of seeming to frustrate those who are anxious for a quick fix or a clearly identifiable scapegoat.  We believe, however, that to frame the problem more narrowly, seeking a simple answer in micro-level interactions or in monolithic constructs, such as racial or class discrimination is to miss the opportunity to view the big picture.  The overrepresentation of minorities in special education is not a phenomenon that exists in a vacuum.  Indeed, minorities are overrepresented in many of the society’s most detrimental circumstances, such as the justice system and among the homeless, while being underserved by the health care system and underrepresented in the nation’s most powerful institutions, such as the U.S. Senate and the leading television networks.”

Source: Harry, B. & Klinger, J. (2006) Why Are So Many Minority Students in Special Education? Understanding Race & Disability in Schools. New York: Teachers College Press, p. 182.

No comments:

Post a Comment